Search

Saved articles

You have not yet added any article to your bookmarks!

Browse articles

GDPR Compliance

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. By continuing to use our site, you accept our use of cookies, Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service.

Wish You Were Here

 
A. A. Lewis Review by A. A. Lewis 4 Published: 20 Aug 2025 theSpace @ Niddry St Show Dates: 17 Aug 2025-19 Aug 2025

Pink Floyd’s Wish You Were Here plays as audiences pile into theSpace @ Niddry Street’s studio, of course. The song speaks for itself; its themes are self-explanatory and somewhat foreshadow what’s to come in this new play from Without Compromise Theatre.

Without Compromise Theatre is a company to watch

Wish You Were Here – the play, that is – unfolds in Glenrothes over the course of one tense engagement party. Three working-class men are brought back together after three years of estrangement: one now lives in Edinburgh and works in theatre, while the others have remained in Fife; one a reformed addict now engaged and expecting a child, the other an unemployed couch surfer dependent on his friends for shelter, food, and drugs to forget the trauma of his mother’s passing. Once a tightly-knit group, these men’s relationships are tested in brutally tense and surprisingly hilarious scenarios throughout the domestic gathering, often toeing the lines between dark comedy and bona fide tragedy.

At its best, Wish You Were Here settles into theatrical naturalism, where dialogue sounds almost impromptu and off-the-cuff – perhaps some of it is – using the Central Scots dialect and slang to draw attention to the difficulty of genuine emotional expression, or at least clarity of expression, in male friendships. An example might be two of the male characters hugging it out very frankly, with one of them fighting back tears by saying something along the lines of, “You’re the best cunt I’ve ever met.”

Moments like these are laugh-out-loud funny, as audience responses attest, but also deeply heartfelt and earnest in delivery and impact. The relationships are fully sketched, characters developed, and themes extracted: from queerness and self-acceptance to drug addiction and cycles of violence. By the end, every narrative turn feels legitimate, if slightly rushed, and unapologetic based on the complexities of these characters’ actions and motivations. Having disarmed its audience with boyish humour, the dreadful realities of grief and addiction catch us off guard and offer some semblance of perspective come the play’s close. This is a brilliant and critical entry in this year’s Fringe; one of the first I have seen that deals head-on with contemporary Scottish themes, culture, and society.

Needless to say, Without Compromise Theatre is a company to watch.

Related to this article:

Location:

Performances

The Blurb:

Set in a small town in Fife, Wish You Were Here follows a trio of working-class young men who are brought together for the first time in three years. Once a tightly-knit found family, time and circumstance has pulled the men apart. On the night of an engagement party, secrets are revealed and relationships are pushed to the brink. Will the group make it through this or have they been torn apart for good? This dark comedy explores themes of mental health, drug culture and homophobia in working-class areas in Scotland.