Search

Saved articles

You have not yet added any article to your bookmarks!

Browse articles

GDPR Compliance

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. By continuing to use our site, you accept our use of cookies, Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service.

The Riskiest Show on the Fringe

22 Jul 2026

Kate Smurthwaite and political activism are like Italian food and garlic: you probably could have one without the other, but what would be the point?

I’ve never understood comedians doing a work-in-progress in February. It’s an hour of dicking about.

Since her first show in 2006 - and alongside the longstanding Comedy Manifesto and News At Kate, politics and feminism and religion and a goodly chunk of science (oh yes, you will get actual facts from this woman - she has a degree in Mathematics from Oxford, no less) have been the main ingredients of the Smurthwaite Comedy Salad.

This year, she may well have taken leave of her not inconsiderable senses, and will be writing and performing an entirely new, hour-long show every night.

At a Fringe where certain comics are charging ridiculous amounts to watch their “WIP” and where some are charging even more to see the SAME show people paid to see last year as WIP, simply brought back, Smurthwaite is pretty much everything a comedy Fringe should be about.

And we had a chat ...

Have you gone absolutely mental ?

Gone? I mean maybe, but also I always write my shows in a couple of weeks. I’ve never understood comedians doing a work-in-progress in February. It’s an hour of dicking about. Just get on with it. My shows have always been political (to varying degrees) so if I wrote them in March they’d be obsolete by Fringe.

Is this some sort of attempt to get yourself an ADHD diagnosis ?

Almost the opposite. I can’t stand our three-minute-attention-span culture. Being expected to answer messages within five minutes, and release hourly social media updates. I’m really looking forward to a good excuse to ignore everyone and spend ten hours a day writing.

Have you considered an exit strategy if it all goes horribly wrong ?

Yes. If I can’t keep up, which is absolutely possible and arguably likely, I’ll do a best-of the shows I’ve written so far for a day or two until I’m done crying.

Is this one of these set ups like TV improv where all the performers actually have stuff prepared and the set ups are geared to that ?

No. So firstly it’s all based on audience suggestions (in person at shows or by email to [email protected]) so I can't prepare a bunch of material. I'll open the inbox live on stage at the end of the previous show for transparency.

I admit I've pulled together a big file of jokes and skits I've written over the years and not used. And I've written stacks of little one-liner jokes that I may be able to pepper into scripts. But it's down to the public to make sure they ask for interesting, unexpected things. For the Oxford preview I had four emails. None of them mentioned anything I had anticipated. Nothing from my big file was useful.

Do you think you will have FUN with this ??

Yes. I've wanted to do this for years. As various people around me are aware. I'm fifty now and it occurred to me that this is hardly going to be easier when I'm fifty-five so that's why I realised if I'm going to do it, I should do it.

I love writing. I love putting it all together. Structuring shows. I've written material for hundreds of other comedians over the years (not usually whole shows I might add, just extra lines, helping them tighten up a script, figure out the structure, spotting great ideas in their previews that need developing further). I enjoy that side of comedy hugely.

I confess I've no doubt at some point I'll probably decide it's all too much and have a panic and a cry but to be honest I do that every Fringe at some point. On the other hand I'll learn so much from it. I'll come away with so much material to use. I'll be a different comedian. And I'll have a great story to tell.

Do you think the AUDIENCE will have fun ?

There are three ways to enjoy this as an audience member.

The first is just to come along and see a comedy show. I'll post the title and the theme of the show on Instagram the evening before - see what's coming up and come along to a show.

Secondly send in ideas by email or at the show the day before and come back and see what I've done with them. Something really personal to you? Or something you think will be difficult to write comedy about? Something you know about my life or interests that you've wanted me to do a show about?

Thirdly, and I would really love for people to do this... Bring a friend who doesn't know about the story of the show. Don't tell them it's been written in 24 hours. See if they realise. I'd love to know what people think of the shows without the extra credit.

There you have it. A terrific comic putting it all on the line for you.

So just remember, if it all falls apart for lack of decent ideas and suggestions, it will be YOUR fault. No pressure.

Related to this article:

Doon Leith