Search

Saved articles

You have not yet added any article to your bookmarks!

Browse articles

GDPR Compliance

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. By continuing to use our site, you accept our use of cookies, Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service.

Scottish Opera: Trial by Jury & A Matter of Misconduct! 

 
Mark Harding Review by Mark Harding 4 Published: 31 May 2025 Edinburgh Festival Theatre Show Dates: 30 May 2025-6 Jun 2025

Scottish Opera delivers a gleefully cynical goodie bag of the old and new in this double bill of operettas – Gilbert & Sullivan's Trial by Jury and the brand-new A Matter of Misconduct!

Reminiscent of The Thick of It, but raunchier, and with added cynicism

Celebrating 150 years since Trial by Jury became G&S's first hit, director John Savournin sets the trial within a reality TV show, complete with ‘Applause’ and ‘Boo’ lights. This works seamlessly with the camp humour of the piece.

The jilted bride Angelina, still in her wedding dress, is suing her ex-betrothed for all she can get. The jilter, Edwin, suggests he marry Angelina – plus his new love. The Judge’s legal expertise is such that he accepts this solution – until the plaintiff’s counsel points out that bigamy is a crime.

Richard Suart squeezes every comedy pip as the flattery-loving, roguish Judge, while Jamie MacDougall’s Edwin sings beautifully with wit and clarity. The major role of the Usher is sung and acted commandingly by Scottish Opera Emerging Artist Edward Jowle.

No potential joke goes unexploited. Highlights include the dancing bridesmaids (where did they get those dresses!), the judge’s mobile pulpit, and the ever-present stage business.

A Matter of Misconduct! is reminiscent of The Thick of It – but raunchier, and with added cynicism. Set in Downing Street, Roger Penistone is in the running for party leadership, but his Spad, Sandy Hogg, has got wind of breaking scandals: one involving Roger, and one involving his wife, Cherry – a ‘Poundshop Paltrow’ with a women’s wellness business.

Enter Sylvia Lawless of Lawless, Lawless, Lawless and Crook, who explains that mud doesn't stick if you're suitably rich, then tackles the scandals through denial, lawsuits, intimidation, and bribery.

Emma Jenkins’ libretto sparkles with raunchy rhymes, ingenious insults, and political misdemeanours that seem somehow familiar…

Toby Hession’s score is full of colour and interest – including a cool jazz section and a wonderful marriage duet that could be slotted into an uplifting Broadway musical. Hession (a former Scottish Opera Emerging Artist) also conducts both operas, leading an orchestra playing with clarity, brio, and a sense of fun.

Jamie MacDougall (unrecognisable from the first half) plays Sandy Hogg with superb comic belligerence. The double bill gives current Scottish Opera Emerging Artist singers a welcome opportunity to shine. Here, Ross Cumming shows his acting and singing chops as Penistone – moving from Johnsonian buffoonery through love song to meltdown – and he is well matched by Chloe Harris as Cherry. Lawless is played by Kira Kaplan, her charisma and coloratura making a dominating impact.

The plot has more holes than Swiss cheese, but Laura Attridge’s tight direction keeps momentum ticking like a Swiss watch.

Related to this article:

Location:

Performances

The Blurb:

Scottish Opera: Trial by Jury

New production accompanied by the world premiere of Emma Jenkins & Toby Hession's A Matter of Misconduct! in a double-bill evening.With a comic cast performing contrasting roles in both pieces, Trial by Jury / A Matter of Misconduct!  promises an unmissable night of classic G&S comedy and new writing. 

Trial by Jury

First performed in 1875, this is the first major hit from the partnership of WS Gilbert and Arthur Sullivan. Set around a classic case of broken vows - the defendant having literally left the claimant at the altar - the trial bubbles over with emotion, humour, and downright chaos, leaving the jury divided. How will they decide between the charming yet swindling defendant and the utterly captivating claimant?   

A Matter of Misconduct!  

Following the crowd-pleasing political satire In Flagrante, which premiered on the 2023/24 Opera Highlights tour, Emma Jenkins and Toby Hession present a daring new operetta set in the press room at Number 9 Downing Street.   

When a scandal threatens to break about the frontrunner in a bloody leadership campaign, a lawyer is needed to prevent information from reaching the press. Sylvia Lawless from the firm Lawless, Lawless, Lawless and Crook must find the loopholes in this modern take on unsavoury behaviour.

Trial by Jury is a new co-production by Scottish Opera, D'Oyly Carte Opera and Opera Holland ParkA Matter of Misconduct! is a new co-commission and co-production by Scottish Opera and D'Oyly Carte OperaTrial by Jury and A Matter of Misconduct! are presented as a double bill

Content warning:Contains jokes, some of which are really naughty.There's no swearing in it, but quite a bit of innuendo.

Sung in English with English supertitles