How To Disappear

As Scotland’s self-declared “new writing theatre”, Edinburgh’s Traverse does like to offer up an alternative to the pantomimes and decidedly family-focused fare on offer elsewhere around the city, while still utilising fake snow. Morna Pearson’s new award-winning play, How to Disappear, certainly fits the bill—even if, initially, it feels out of time. It’s no “I, Daniel Blake”, but Pearson’s focus on oppressive bureaucracy surely isn’t most people’s idea of festive fun.

How to Disappear appears to be an engaging, and finely tuned examination of mental illness

Admittedly, that’s partly because, almost from the get-go, How to Disappear is funny—surprisingly so. Owen Whitelaw has played quite a few intense, even violent characters in recent years, but he’s a revelation here: his Robert is a naively optimistic creature who is emotionally and intellectually focused inwards, a man-child who hasn’t left his bedroom for 12 years, or in two decades stepped out of the house that he shares with his younger sister Isla. Robert’s hair is matted, his skin cracked and peeling; as a social human being he is barely functioning. Enter his benefits accessor Jessica.

Jessica’s determination—to (a) fill out her forms, and (b) prove that Robert is actually fit for work—is invariably played for comedy, as we see the unstoppable pigeon-holing mentality of the DWP crash against the seemingly immovable realities of Robert and Isla’s dead-end lives. Sally Reid has a real talent for landing the laughs without sacrificing any emotional realism, although it’s fair to say that she benefits from being given a character who is shown some depths from the start; sadly, in comparison, Kirsty Mackay is given little beyond shouty victimhood through which to gain our sympathies.

All in all, How to Disappear appears to be an engaging, and finely tuned examination of mental illness and how people can all-too-easily “disappear” from society. Yet that’s not enough for Morna Pearson; she has a twist up her sleeve, and I don’t just mean the totally unexpected set-change, which designer Becky Minto should be praised for. To avoid “Spoilers”, I won’t say any more, beyond that the second half successfully establishes a radically different framework to explain what’s been going on. As theatrical conceptual breakthroughs go, it effectively underscores and adds pathos to the whole situation.

Director Gareth Nicholls does an excellent job here, not least in keeping the play’s momentum going between scenes, which sometimes involve jumping back and forward over time while the cast shift props in the semi-darkness, our attention focused instead on the flickering digits of Robert’s bedside digital clock. Importantly, he ensures that the finale, while possibly too saccharine for some tastes, nevertheless effectively offers a resolution that fits the seasonal context of this production.

Reviews by Paul F Cockburn

Traverse Theatre

Mbuzeni

★★★★
Traverse Theatre

Expedition Peter Pan

★★★★
North Edinburgh Arts Centre

Stick By Me

★★★★
The Brunton, Musselburgh

Gretel and Hansel

★★★★
Multiple Venues

Eddie and the Slumber Sisters

★★★
The Lyceum

Creditors

★★★

Performances

Location

The Blurb

When Helen Daniels from Neighbours died, Robert shut his door on the world. Now his only connection is his younger sister Isla—until benefit assessor Jessica arrives to prove he’s fit for work… But one size doesn’t fit all in this pitch-black comedy.