Search

Toggle dark mode:

Saved articles

You have not yet added any article to your bookmarks!

Browse articles

GDPR Compliance

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. By continuing to use our site, you accept our use of cookies, Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service.

The Makropulos Affair

 
Mark Harding Review by Mark Harding 4 Published: 1 Mar 2025 Edinburgh Festival Theatre Show Dates: 27 Feb 2025-1 Mar 2025

The greatest operatic soprano in the world, with an irresistible beauty, who is 300 years old, preserved by an occult elixir – that is some role. If the thought of playing this was intimidating, there is no indication of that in Orla Boylan’s superb performance as Emilia Marty / Ellian MacGregor / Eugenia Montez / Elina Makropulos. Emilia is rude, selfish, mocking and dismissive. Yet Boylan manages a delicious balance between these aspects while providing an attractive sense of rascally humour, with occasional flashes of physical weakness; features which reinforce the impact of the final denouement. Boylan provides a level of acting and singing that is appropriately supernatural.

A showcase of talent

This Scottish Opera production of Janáček’s The Makropulos Affair is a showcase of talent. Another highly successful co-production, this time with Welsh National Opera, it brings to Scotland the direction of the acclaimed Olivia Fuchs, the ingenious and felicitous sets by Nicola Turner, lighting by Robbie Butler and video by Sam Sharpes. It combines these elements with Scottish Opera's accomplished Orchestra conducted by Martyn Brabbins (making his company debut) and a new cast (with the exception of Mark Le Brocq, who also sang the role of Vivek for WNO).

The cast sings in English with a clarity that makes the surtitles largely redundant. Each cast member brings something special. Le Brocq not only aces the comedy in the first act but also, in tandem with Catriona Hewitson playing the novice opera-singer Kristina, brings a wonderful sense of a father-daughter relationship. Hewitson's expressive singing and characterisation bring a moral center to the action, which, with the exception of Vivek, is largely dominated by men behaving like spoilt children

Roland Wood perfectly captures the entitled, bullying Baron Prus, pushing the role as far as possible while avoiding pantomime villain territory. Due to the indisposition of Ryan Capozzo, Thorbjørn Gulbrandsøy took the major part of Albert Gregor with a fine performance, although he sometimes lacked the high standard of enunciation. Henry Waddington’s Dr Kolenatý is perhaps underused. Michael Lafferty plays Baron Prus’s son with a mixture of irritating soppiness and Succession-style daddy issues, while the aged lecher, Count Hauk-Šendorf, is played by Alasdair Elliott with a suitable sense of comedy and selfishness.

Janáček's libretto stays faithful to the source play by Karel Čapek. So be warned, if you are not aware: there are no arias in this opera. However, be assured, this is no loss, as Janáček constantly provides a musical flow of interest and charm. His work is a model of marrying the music of the words (in David Pountney's masterly translation of the libretto) with the music of the orchestra.

Is The Makropulos Affair a feminist tale – Emilia’s character shaped by the cruelties she endured in her youth? Or a comedy about a person who has reached the age where they don’t care what other people think? Or a tragedy about the awful tedium of living too long? A night at the opera with comedy, tragedy, music, and something to think about.

Amir Nisi

Mark Harding

Mark has reviewed books, film, drama, dance and opera for multiple publications. His stories have been published in various magazines. He lives in Edinburgh.

Related to this article:

Location:

Performances

The Blurb:

Hailed as an ‘unmissable triumph’ (The Telegraph) and nominated for a 2022 Southbank Sky Arts Award, this co-production of Janáček’s mature masterpiece returns to Scottish Opera in its first full staging since 1993.  

Emilia Marty is a stylish, enigmatic diva with a secret. For over three centuries, she has lived many lives, in a quest to become a great opera singer. Emilia, also known as Elina Makropulos, or E.M., captivates minds and hearts along her journey through time and across Europe. Her existence raises questions of science and nature, reality and fantasy, and life and death. But as the elixir she was given begins to lose its power, the secrets of her lives and loves begin to come to light. She can no longer escape from these essential human tensions.    

Olivia Fuchs’ ‘emotionally driven direction’ (The Telegraph) is supported by Nicola Turner’s multi-layered, poetic designs. Sung in English, Orla Boylan (Marx in London! 2024) leads as Emilia Marty, with Ryan Capozzo (Scottish Opera debut) as Albert Gregor. Joining them are Henry Waddington (Greek 2018) as Doctor Kolenatý, and Mark Le Brocq (Nixon in China 2020) as Vitek.  The Orchestra of Scottish Opera, conducted Martyn Brabbins, brings out every dramatic nuance.

Sung in English with English supertitles 

The Producers
The Play That Goes Wrong
Matilda
Popular now
4

Mabel

Durham Fringe Festival
Phantom of the Opera
Lion King