The Dispute

Who was first unfaithful: woman or man? A scientific experiment designed to recreate the garden of Eden and answer this question “once and for all” is the premise of this heavily modernised version of Pierre de Marivaux’s 1744 original.

Relying on a question posed by theological debate long since rendered mute results in a lack of intellectually coherent material with which to grapple

This question had some resonance in 1744, as did the ‘Wild Child’ theme that underpins the play. Four teenagers are brought up in isolation and on day 6570 they are let out into the world to encounter their sexual counterparts for the first time. Nature leads the way, whilst being pushed by a sinister experiment supervisor, embodied in a monitor atop a glass mannequin.

In 2014, this question doesn’t make a lot of sense. We’re 270 years more clued up as to how men and women work. Biblical questions have far less relevance to us in light of Ross and Rachel’s relationship in Friends. Relying on a question posed by theological debate long since rendered mute results in a lack of intellectually coherent material with which to grapple. The too-tempting answer is: ‘Who cares?’ We’ve discovered that it’s the complexities in human relationships that make them interesting, not the simple beginnings.

However, the direction and design in this adaptation are excellent. The aforementioned glass mannequin is a fascinating object; it would not be out of place in some of the exhibitions currently filling Summerhall. The symmetrical, minimalist stage is utilised very well, with the blocking clever and effective throughout. Projected video sequences are well sourced and edited, and add something essential to the atmosphere of the piece.

The cast is a young one and obviously very talented. However, sometimes the Shakespeare-in-the-park exaggeration of movement and diction jars with the modernity of text and production. The dialogue, whilst often charming, occasionally strays into near-cringe niceness. There is not enough of the sinister here to bring de Marivaux’s ideas to life.

Whilst initially an interesting thought experiment, The Dispute doesn’t seem to be a play that translates well for a modern audience. Now that we have exploded biblical ideas about man and woman, the question loses its essential meaning, ruining the possibility of complex analysis. This means that, in the end, we’re just watching some teenagers frolicking beside a stream, and laughing at how silly they are. There are more interesting ways of exploring the human condition.

Reviews by James Macnamara


Government Inspector

Stand in the Square

Is Your Marmite Watching You?

The Jazz Bar

Jazz Rite of Spring

Underbelly, Bristo Square

Rachel Stubbings: Doing It for Himself

C venues - C nova

Cabaret Nova

The Edinburgh Academy

West Side Story


Since you’re here…

… we have a small favour to ask. We don't want your money to support a hack's bar bill at Abattoir, but if you have a pound or two spare, we really encourage you to support a good cause. If this review has either helped you discover a gem or avoid a turkey, consider doing some good that will really make a difference.

You can donate to the charity of your choice, but if you're looking for inspiration, there are three charities we really like.

Mama Biashara
Kate Copstick’s charity, Mama Biashara, works with the poorest and most marginalised people in Kenya. They give grants to set up small, sustainable businesses that bring financial independence and security. That five quid you spend on a large glass of House White? They can save someone’s life with that. And the money for a pair of Air Jordans? Will take four women and their fifteen children away from a man who is raping them and into a new life with a moneymaking business for Mum and happiness for the kids.
Donate to Mama Biashara now

Theatre MAD
The Make A Difference Trust fights HIV & AIDS one stage at a time. Their UK and International grant-making strategy is based on five criteria that raise awareness, educate, and provide care and support for the most vulnerable in society. A host of fundraising events, including Bucket Collections, Late Night Cabarets, West End Eurovision, West End Bares and A West End Christmas continue to raise funds for projects both in the UK and Sub-Saharan Africa.
Donate to Theatre MAD now

Acting For Others
Acting for Others provides financial and emotional support to all theatre workers in times of need through the 14 member charities. During the COVID-19 crisis Acting for Others have raised over £600,000 to support theatre workers affected by the pandemic.
Donate to Acting For Others now



The Blurb

Day 6,570. The culmination of an experiment to recreate the Garden of Eden. Four teenagers locked away, never glimpsing another human face. Today they will be released. Director Emily Kempson reimagines Marivaux’s dizzyingly dark, erotic tale.

Most Popular See More

Come From Away

From £25.00

More Info

Find Tickets


From £29.00

More Info

Find Tickets

Matilda the Musical

From £25.00

More Info

Find Tickets

The Lion King

From £45.00

More Info

Find Tickets

Life of Pi

From £19.00

More Info

Find Tickets


From £31.00

More Info

Find Tickets