In the mid-1990s, Randy Newman's song cycle about a contemporary deal with the Devil was staged in Los Angeles and Chicago, but never made it to Broadway. Now Mr. Newman, abetted by Encore's Off-Center series, will give this musical based on Goethe's epic its New York premiere for a one-night concert performance. He will star as Mephistopheles, with Michael Cerveris as an angel, Laura Osnes as Margaret and Tony Vincent as Faust. Thomas Kail directs.