Mamma Mia!

Reviewing Mamma Mia! almost feels like a lost cause; it’s an unstoppable global phenomenon and, if this touring production—setting up home in the Edinburgh Playhouse for Christmas and New Year—has any shortcomings, audiences love it none-the-less. This is despite this particular production not being best suited to such a large venue; regardless of the show’s reliance on Mediterranean blues and a bleached white set, it all feels a tad cold and small in what remains Scotland’s largest traditional theatre.

The overall sound of the show is closer to pop rather than full-blooded orchestra

Admittedly, when it comes to jukebox musicals, Mamma Mia! has a lot to apologise for, although it remains among best in breed—it at least has a genuine story, even if the central narrative thrust—20 year old Sophie wanting to find out which of three potential candidates is her father—could now be easily solved by a few DNA tests. (Mamma Mia!, it’s often forgotten, is set some time in the 1990s.) Thanks to a few tweaked lyrics here and there, most of the oh-so-well-known ABBA songs slot into their narrative roles effectively enough, although some remain slightly distracting while others are resolutely square pegs forced into round holes. (The Winner Takes It All is arguably the worst example.) In truth, Mamma Mia! demands a certain degree of forgiveness, but invariably gets it—partly down to nostalgia, but also because it remains a gloriously female-centric show.

The scale of this particular touring production is best reflected in the live music, the “band” consisting of three keyboards, three guitars and some percussion. The overall sound of the show is closer to pop rather than full-blooded orchestra which, while fine for most of the songs, disappoints during the overture and other “orchestral” lead-ins. This also puts more pressure on the cast’s vocal talents which rest most strongly on Sara Poyzer as single mum Donna Sheridan and Lucy May Barker as her about-to-get-married daughter Sophie. Both have strong voices, although Barker’s has an unfortunate harsh edge on occasions; but they are, for the most part, stronger than the male performers surrounding them.

Richard Standing, as Donna’s principal love interest Sam Carmichael, is arguably the strongest vocalist among the three “fathers”, but even he has few opportunities in which to flex his vocal chords. Given his ultimate role in proceedings, it’s unfortunate that we’re given little reason to believe in the chemistry between him and Donna. (In contrast, arguably the most believable relationships is that played between Donna and “impulsive” banking man Harry Bright—played by Tim Walton—during a playful take on Our Last Summer). The production’s habit of freezing certain characters in spotlights while another sings, doesn’t help build these connections.

There are, of course, laughs to be had; not least from Jacqueline Braun and Emma Clifford as Donna’s old performing partners Rosie and Tanya, who are both seeking love in their own ways. Overall, though, this is a production that feels rather less than the sum of its parts; it hints at why Mamma Mia! is such a global hit, but doesn’t exactly explain how.

Reviews by Paul F Cockburn

Multiple Venues


Dundee Rep Theatre / Macrobert Arts Centre

The Yellow on the Broom

Underbelly, Bristo Square

Tom Neenan: It's Always Infinity

Assembly George Square Studios

Police Cops in Space

Gilded Balloon Rose Theatre

Rik Carranza: Still a Fan

Gilded Balloon Rose Theatre





The Blurb

Join the ultimate feel-good party at Mamma Mia!, the world’s sunniest and most exhilarating smash-hit musical!

Set on a Greek island paradise, a story of love, friendship and identity is cleverly told through the timeless songs of ABBA. Sophie’s quest to discover the father she’s never known brings her mother face to face with three men from her distant romantic past on the eve of a wedding they’ll never forget.

This irresistibly funny show has been thrilling audiences all around the world and now the party will continue, so there’s never been a better time to see this unforgettable musical. Whatever age you are, you can’t help but have the time of your life at Mamma Mia!