On February 7th 1991, James Casey was found guilty of murder. He was sentenced to life imprisonment and is still in jail today. He is innocent This short narrative will concentrate on a crazy error made by the judge while instructing the jury. The judge destroyed James Caseys defence by saying, in relation to his principal argument, that the logic of it escapes me' This is not the only reason James Casey did not get a fair trial. To explore the many structural flaws in the Scottish Legal System, see https://fairtrialproject.org/.