James Acaster: The Trelogy – Recognise

James Acaster is a comedian who, for many, requires no introduction. He has achieved enormous success at the Fringe, with the shows he has brought to Edinburgh over the last five years earning a record-breaking five consecutive nominations for ‘Best Comedy Show’. He has become a regular face on television on comedy panel shows such as Mock the Week. He’s on the cusp of becoming a household name across the country. All things considered, I’ll be perfectly honest and admit that there’s probably not much I can say about him that hasn’t been said before, especially of a trio of shows that repeats material from his last three Fringe hits.

An animated stand-alone hour of stand up comedy from a titan of the Fringe.

Recognise (2014), Represent (2015) and Reset (2016) make up 2017’s The Trelogy, performed on consecutive nights. The first of these, Recognise is delivered in the character of Pat Springleaf: a man whose wife has just left him and who believes he is an undercover cop currently posing as a member of a drug ring.

Acaster’s comic charm is based in the persona he inhabits onstage. Here, I don't mean Pat Springleaf specifically, but a version of James Acaster that he has cultivated for comedy: gawky, characteristically dressed in slacks, and reminiscent of a collection of the nation’s geography teachers. It gave him a unique style when he broke into the comedy scene, and is undoubtedly still a key selling point of his act.

His material itself is consistently hilarious, too, particularly in the unexpected nature of its humour, often generated from almost nothing. Seemingly insignificant everyday things like buying a banana in Prêt à Manger are made side-splittingly funny, over-analysed to the point of spoof. Still, it's chiefly something about his delivery, his distinctive rhotacism and deadpan facial expressions perhaps, that has so captured the attention of the British public. There is a danger of Acaster as a performer slipping into a parody of his onstage self, of pushing the initially original persona beyond believability and into gimmick. However, there is still enough Recognise-able truth behind his observations to feel relatable, and the fictitious nature and wacky ingenuity of his stand-up allow for a slightly heightened performance state.

Individually, Recognise is an animated stand-alone hour of stand up comedy from a titan of the Fringe. In combination with the rest of The Trelogy Acaster’s shows Represent the evolution of his stand up from 2014 to 2016, and Reset the clock on his material. An excuse to retell old jokes perhaps, but his are, after all, pretty good ones.

Reviews by Laura Pujos

Pleasance Courtyard

Kae Kurd: Kurd Your Enthusiasm

Paradise in The Vault


Heroes @ Dragonfly

Thom Tuck: An August Institution

Pleasance Courtyard

James Acaster: The Trelogy – Recognise

Laughing Horse @ The Counting House

The Breakup Monologues

theSpace @ Jury's Inn

Man and Boy




The Blurb

Undercover cops. Jury duty. Witness protection. Comedy. All this and more as James Acaster, Edinburgh Comedy Award Best Show Nominee (Recognise, 2014, Represent, 2015, Reset, 2016) brings a trilogy of shows back to the Fringe, beginning with Recognise. He doesn't know who he is, he doesn't know what he believes and he doesn't know what he's going to do with his life. He'll probably do material from his first three shows as well. It's going to be a huge recap.