A Charlie Montague Mystery: The Game's a Foot, Try the Fish

What would an unpublished Agatha Christie mystery be like if, by some strange quirk of fate, its editor had given it over to P G Wodehouse for a final literary polish? Well, thanks to Tom Taylor, we now have at least an idea; a bit like one-man-show The Game’s A Foot, Try the Fish—a hit during last year’s Fringe, back again along with brand new adventure The Man With The Twisted Hip.

Character comedy that, like Charlie Montague himself, is actually nowhere near as silly as you might think.

Admittedly, one man’s homage is another man’s pastiche, but Taylor clearly knows what he’s writing about; so ‘rakish aristocrat’ (according to the Fringe programme) Charlie Montague is a naturally endearing character, a bumbling innocent abroad—well, Dorset—seemingly soon out of his depth. For Charlie, on a whim, has set himself up as a consulting detective. Some judicious advertisements in the morning newspapers speedily secure his first case—to prevent the death of failing actor, Rex Hamilton, and he speedily travels down to the Cliff House Hotel to join both intended victim and an entourage of potential suspects.

That we have a reasonably positive image of Charlie is in no small part because, while he’s obviously our narrator, there appears to be no guile in the man as he explains the plot and performs the other characters, or at least those Taylor (as Charlie) can do voices for—an example of the script’s witty self-awareness regarding the limits of the “set” (a chaise longue on an otherwise empty stage) or its sole performer’s vocal range. Indeed, on occasions, Taylor’s a blur as he slips from narrator, to character, to speaking directly to the audience about their reactions.

If Taylor has a potential weakness as a stage performer, it’s an apparent reluctance to ever look his audience straight in the eye. As a writer, however, he really excels; while some jokes are pretty obvious, others are far more subtly rooted in both narrative and character, often coming to fruition when you least expect it. The result: character comedy that, like Charlie Montague himself, is actually nowhere near as silly as you might think.

Reviews by Paul F Cockburn

Traverse Theatre

Arctic Oil

Multiple Venues


Multiple Venues


Dundee Rep Theatre / Macrobert Arts Centre

The Yellow on the Broom

Underbelly, Bristo Square

Tom Neenan: It's Always Infinity

Assembly George Square Studios

Police Cops in Space




The Blurb

Rakish aristocrat and first-time detective Charlie Montague must prevent a murder. The chap dies. Sell-out show 2016. PG Wodehouse meets Agatha Christie in this hilarious, one-man murder mystery from award-winning comedian and writer Tom Taylor (as heard on BBC Radio 4's New Comedy Award). ‘A gloriously silly murder mystery that delights its audience’ **** (Stage). ‘A show so funny at one point I thought my lungs were going to burst ... a masterpiece in the genre’ **** (BroadwayBaby.com). ‘Astoundingly funny’ **** (FringeGuru.com).